by the Mormon Curtain
In 1828, Martin Harris, acting as scribe for Joseph Smith, recorded the
first 116 pages of The Book of Mormon. He asked permission of Joseph
Smith to let him borrow these pages to take home with him so he could
show them to his wife.
Martin’s wife was very skeptical and feared that
her wealthy husband was being conned out of his money in order to get
the Book of Mormon published for Joseph. Joseph inquired of the Lord to
know if he might do as Martin Harris had requested, but was refused.
Joseph inquired again, but received a second refusal. Still, Martin
Harris persisted as before, and Joseph applied again, but the last
answer was not like the two former ones. In this the Lord permitted
Martin Harris to take the manuscript home with him. Three weeks later
Mr. Harris returned to Joseph and told him that he had lost the 116
pages.
Joseph was very distraught over this, exclaiming "Oh, my God! All is
lost! All is lost! What shall I do? I have sinned." It is widely
believed that Martin Harris’ wife had taken the pages. The reasoning was
that if Joseph was indeed a prophet he could re translate those same
pages exactly as before and that would prove he was actually translating
instead of just making up the Book of Mormon story as he dictated to
Martin. Finally, Joseph inquired of the Lord as to what he should do; in
response, he received a revelation, which is recorded in section 10 of
the Doctrine & Covenants. He was told that he should not retranslate
those lost pages because Satan’s cunning plan was to have evil men
alter the words in the original translation and wait until Joseph
retranslated those pages. The evil men would then produce the original
lost 116 pages with the alterations to prove that Joseph was a fraud.
God, of course, knew of Satan’s eventual plan and had Nephi make two
sets of plates that cover essentially the same material but written a
little differently. Joseph was instructed to now translate from the
large plates of Nephi, instead of the smaller, abridged plates of Nephi
that he had translated from earlier. This way the same basic information
that should be included in the Book of Mormon was there, but it would
not be expected to match exactly the original lost 116 pages that were
first translated by Joseph.
The official story taught and recorded by the church is non-sensical for the following reasons:
1) The evil men that were conspiring to alter the original documents
could not have done so without it being very obvious that the original
document was altered. When Martin Harris was scribing for Joseph, he
didn’t use a pencil and paper. Martin wrote with ink on foolscap. Any
alteration would be very noticeable and not convincing to anyone.
In addition to the rubbing out of old words and rewriting of new words,
the handwriting would have been different. Any rudimentary handwriting
inspection would have determined that it had been altered, especially
easy to determine given that the new handwriting would have occurred in
the same spot as the rubbed out and re-written words.
2) If the evil men that were planning on changing the stolen 116 pages
thought their plan of changing some words from these pages would work to
discredit Joseph they would not have been completely foiled by Joseph
translating from different plates to tell the first part of the Book of
Mormon story. If they thought their alterations would have gone
unnoticed then they would have still tried to alter the 116 pages to
discredit his work.
For example, they could have changed some names of people or places or
altered events that are central to the beginning of the Book of Mormon
and thereby prove that Joseph’s new translation was in error. If they
really thought their alterations would have gone unnoticed they could
have changed the names of Nephi’s brothers or the cities they came from
or many other items that would have been included in both sets of
plates. But they never did this – why? If opponents of the Church really
had the lost 116 pages as Joseph claimed they would have resurfaced in
some form to at least attempt to discredit Joseph, even if they would
not have been successful.
3) The general belief at the time was that Martin Harris’s wife burned
the 116 pages. If she destroyed them, then this entire story is simply
made up by Joseph Smith. But the prophet Joseph evidently was afraid she
had not, but had secretly hidden them, for the purpose of entrapping
him, should he ever attempt to reproduce the pages. If the work was
really of God, the manuscript could be reproduced word for word without a
mistake. If, however, Joseph created it himself, his memory would
hardly be adequate to such a task, without numberless changes or verbal
differences—and thus "give himself away," since he loudly professed to
be all the time aided "by the gift and power of God." Since the lost
pages never surfaced in any form, it is likely that they were destroyed
immediately by Martin Harris’s wife. Therefore, the entire story about
someone altering pages is impossible and just made up by Joseph because
he knew he could not reproduce those same pages as he was not really
translating the Book of Mormon story.
4) It is convenient that the prophets of old just happened to make an
extra set of plates 1500 years ago to cover this contingency, isn’t it?
For further details:
http://www.utlm.org/onlineresources/b...
It’s hard to believe that Satan and some evil men were really behind the
plot to steal the 116 pages. The stolen pages would have eventually
come forth in probably a failed attempt to discredit Joseph. If nothing
else they would have been worth a lot of money so we can’t imagine why
the evil men, if they existed, would not have used the pages to either
try to discredit Smith, ransom them to Martin and Joseph or hold on to
them to eventually sell them. The stolen pages wouldn’t have simply been
destroyed by men who went to such trouble to obtain them.
Instead it seems much more plausible that Martin Harris’ wife had
immediately destroyed the pages to defy her husband. If that’s the case,
is there any other reason why Joseph would make up the story about
Satan’s plan to discredit him? I haven’t found any members that can
explain Joseph’s actions with a reasonable explanation.
To learn more about the Lost 116 Pages: http://www.mormonthink.com/lost116web...
No comments:
Post a Comment